Failing out
Printed From: Advisorheads
Category: Introductions
Forum Name: Greenhorn Introductions
Forum Description: MAKE YOUR FIRST POST HERE!
URL: http://www.advisorheads.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=8118
Printed Date: Mar/26/2026 at 10:08pm Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.03 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Failing out
Posted By: trueindigo
Subject: Failing out
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 6:14pm
As a lurker here trying to decide about this as a career I really only have one question: over and over I read about how many people "fail out" of this industry and the high attrition rate. Exactly how does one define failing out? Does that mean they projected a six figure income and never made it, or what? What exactly does this mean? Thanks to everyone. Great forum.
------------- True Indigo
|
Replies:
Posted By: Chief
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 6:16pm
It means no job..fires..let go..
------------- "You like winning don't you?" "Saves you from having to say the word please."
Good point Chief. Iceco1d 10/30/12
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 6:23pm
Speaking to staff at College for Financial Planning there was no real data on attrition by age, the assumption that younger FP's at 25 right out of college were cannon fodder and had a hard time getting someone 65+ to trust them with their portfolio, as opposed to a middle aged man or woman, etc. From some of the posts I read, sometimes I get the feeling this is a horrific career or, for the too dumb to fail, just the right thing? Really, just an honest query, because the profession sounds very risky. Could you?
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: City1134
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 6:32pm
trueindigo wrote:
Speaking to staff at College for Financial Planning there was no real data on attrition by age, the assumption that younger FP's at 25 right out of college were cannon fodder and had a hard time getting someone 65+ to trust them with their portfolio, as opposed to a middle aged man or woman, etc. From some of the posts I read, sometimes I get the feeling this is a horrific career or, for the too dumb to fail, just the right thing? Really, just an honest query, because the profession sounds very risky. Could you? |
I think it takes a certain personality to make it in this business, I'm not a veteran by any means, but it's not for everyone. Was talking with my teacher buddy and he asked how much I generally make in a month, I told him between 5-11k and he flipped, said there's no way he could handle the fluctuation (and is happier making 4k consistently). I started pretty young (started at 24, am now 28). I am still fairly young, but pretty large (6'4" 240lbs) and act like an old man so I think it works. If I had a pimply face and hadn't filled out yet I think it would be a lot tougher.
|
Posted By: Army13A
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 7:16pm
|
Failing out means you're not making enough money to support yourself or family. If you're young and have no liabilities, you can survive making 40-50K/year for a number of years while you're building a business/trail revenue. If out the gate your hurdle to break even is 5-8K/month, that's tough.
|
Posted By: mobile2
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 7:54pm
|
Failing out = not generating enough revenue, either by commissions or fees, for the firm to keep you around. One day you're there and then you're not.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 8:09pm
Thank you for your help. I can survive on vapors.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 8:10pm
Thank you for your input. Nothing is easy. Nothing.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Delbs
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 8:18pm
|
Just do it, especially if your young. If you succeed you can have an unbelievable lifestyle. If you fail, you probably only gave up a year or two of your working career. Its worth the risk.
Also, you can be young and act young. Or you can be young and exude confidence and act like a leader.
Your choice and the clients can tell.
|
Posted By: B24
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 8:56pm
Delbs wrote:
Just do it, especially if your young. If you succeed you can have an unbelievable lifestyle. If you fail, you probably only gave up a year or two of your working career. Its worth the risk.
Also, you can be young and act young. Or you can be young and exude confidence and act like a leader.
Your choice and the clients can tell. |
^This.
When you are young and have few responsibilities (wife, kids, house, etc.), there is no reason not to swing for the fences. But the key is, you have to be willing to work your balls off to make it happen, and work SMART (in other words figure out the right way to be successful).
I wish I had happened upon this business before I had kids.
You have to think of it as starting your own business. Read Inc. Magazine and many of the stories about how people built businesses. Yes it's a sales business early on, but ALL businesses are pretty much sales businesses.
The one downside of this career/business, is that you are (for most advisors) constantly selling to consumers, not other businesses. So the sales cycle and psychology needed for success is much different than in B2B industries. I think this is why people that think they are great "salespeople" often fail out of this business.
|
Posted By: JYD
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 10:40pm
|
People fail out because almost everyone I have ever seen get into this business underestimates how otherwise rational people get completely irrational about how they approach their money. Nothing happens on your time frame. You have to work incredibly hard, and many days without reward. You will fail so much more often than you succeed. That is hard on a psyche. I guess I was just dumb enough to not take it personally.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 10:49pm
54. still young enough for me. the only question is am i young enough for ej or another noob position? i know all about the 3 years of 1500 cc's a week, etc. and the beyond stupid dedication to the phones. that's just sticking to the basics. just don't know what failing out means exactly. or the numbers. or why the attrition rates. like that. any global perspectives? thanks for your reply good sir.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 10:56pm
|
thanks b.
no kids. no mortgage. small teacher stipend. second career. cant' imagine working a regular j....j.....ugh....job ever again. doctors, lawyers, business owners, all of them worked their balls off for at least 3-5 years before getting up on step. if that's what it takes to succeed then i'm in. just don't need to crush the jewels needlessly. the general flavor of what i'm seeing here is work like a slave for the first 3-5 and then it's possible to let off on the gas and spend more time advising and less cc'ing. if that's all it takes great, but i also see posts of smart, hard working, dedicated people failing out. so there must be more to this than simply being a workhorse. i'm sure you would say, go for it. nothing to lose. right?
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 11:15pm
|
True Indigo -
Failing out can mean either 1. you don't bring in assets fast enough for the firm to be ok with you and they dump you, and you can't find another firm to take you on. 2. You work your balls off and still can;t bring in enough money to make a living, and you give up, and decide its not for you
As far as being 54, I started at age 49, so just a bit younger than you. I worked my ass off. I'm not a natural, at prospecting, maybe you are, but i can only speak from my experience. Don't remember i think it took me 5 years to get to 100k. If you don't need a lot of money to live and you can find a firm that will be patient, and allow you to grow at your own pace (forget the big dogs, i.e. Merrill, Morgan Stanley, etc,) then you can make it.
And lets say you build a business where you are making 125-150k revenues, in 6-7 years - you can then enjoy that income without working too hard for the next 10, or 15 years if you are lucky enough to stay healthy. The nice thing about this business is that you can work forever, or as long as you want to, and you dont have to work a full week if you build it right.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 11:20pm
|
SF, I wish you would give yourself more credit about prospecting. You're fucking good at it (talking to people, calling, etc.). You're just fucking terrible at DOING it.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 11:31pm
I know there are some flamethrowers on this forum but I just want to thank you sincerely, as one human being to another, don't know who you are, but thank you for being honest and real and really, pretty much giving me the stupidity to think why the hell not. sometimes that's all it takes, just being dumb enough not to know better and smart enough to make it work. thanks man. really. thank you.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 11:38pm
I have a feeling you will do well. By your own standards. Which at this stage of your (and my) life, should be the only standards that count.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/11/2013 at 11:59pm
truth be said. truth be said.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 11:48am
SF, sorry for leaning on you lad, but when you said stay away from the big outfits, I'm assuming you mean also EJ, and instead going to boutiques and RIA's and working for one of those and starting a 500 day war? Just a little more direction and I'm off and running. Thanks again.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 1:30pm
I was referring to the wirehouses, not EJ, although i suspect it is the same with EJ, with whom i have no first hand knowledge, only what i read here from the kool aide types. My point was, at the wires you will be forced to satisfy their standards, not your own. Specifically i mean ML, Morgan Stanley, UBS and Wells, although I Am Legend can speak with more knowledge regarding Wells, i think they are a little less rigid than the others, I am not sure. And i don't know if UBS is even hiring newbies.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: newregrep
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 1:59pm
|
SF,
give yourself some credit man, you're a very like-able guy. Like I said, if I ever LEAVE this business and I have a substantial amount of money, I would have you manage my money and give you full discretion, you're just a trust worthy - type of person. And believe me I don't trust people very easily. You have good game and don't even know it.
Indigo,
You have to be very careful of the big firms. They have changed their wording on their new "agreement" to where if you leave OR get fired, they can come after you for training costs. At big firms it's around 35-40k. Imagine you try the biz out, and don't make it and leave the industry and they still come after you?
You'd have to be crazy to sign those docs...
------------- Helado for Prez
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 3:02pm
Thanks SF, I guess I was asking if you were suggesting bypassing the bigs and instead focus on trying to get in at a boutique or RIA as an assistant, etc to get wet feet. As a noob, very honestly, just finding the trail head is the hardest part. Once you're on the trail all you have to do is follow it where it leads. I think those of us on the outside most need a rough map of how to break in and get on the money trail. Knowledge base, RIA or wire, candy striping, nuzzling someone's nuts at a seminar, etc. How to get on the money trail. Man, that's the hardest part. Thanks again from the bottom of my heart. We all started here at square one.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 5:16pm
|
It depends if you need a salary or not. If you do I would start at EJ or WFA. The other big firms are not good options any longer IMO. If you don't need a salary and you find an independent or RIA office willing to take you on I would go that route if you want to be independent one day.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 5:19pm
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 5:20pm
newregrep wrote:
SF,
give yourself some credit man, you're a very like-able guy. Like I said, if I ever LEAVE this business and I have a substantial amount of money, I would have you manage my money and give you full discretion, you're just a trust worthy - type of person. And believe me I don't trust people very easily. You have good game and don't even know it.
Indigo,
You have to be very careful of the big firms. They have changed their wording on their new "agreement" to where if you leave OR get fired, they can come after you for training costs. At big firms it's around 35-40k. Imagine you try the biz out, and don't make it and leave the industry and they still come after you?
You'd have to be crazy to sign those docs... |
I agree with the highlighted part. SF is probably the most helpful person on the forum although if I left the biz I would manage my own money.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 6:21pm
|
WTF?! You mean I'm not the most helpful person on the forum?
BLASPHEMY!
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 10:02pm
Thanks for your help legend. Ok, so no salary. What are the chances of making rent in 6 months w/o anything than commissions? Not talking living large mind you, just a dog house. Of course I would want to go indy since I'm just not a kool aide kind of guy. And, since I've been reading here you don't need to know much of anything except how to sell and market, what kind of knowledge base is helpful? Also, elsewhere I've seen people say do not go into income deficit to get started, which sounds to be the case with a indy/RIA. Could you take a moment please, and I have to say this is a really great forum with really helpful people. It's very heartening to see this kind of brotherhood.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 10:23pm
|
It depends how much you need to make monthly?? If you need 2-4k per month for living expenses you could do that in 6 months. One of the best skills you can have is how to read people and how to build trust.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/12/2013 at 10:30pm
I'm on this like ugly on a Baldwin brother. Thank you for your help.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 7:54pm
Iamlegend wrote:
It depends how much you need to make monthly?? If you need 2-4k per month for living expenses you could do that in 6 months. One of the best skills you can have is how to read people and how to build trust. |
Someone with no sales experience, no industry experience can make 3k/month in the FIRST 6 months in a commission only based FA role? Do you really feel this way? I'm not mocking you or anything, I truly want to know what you think. I have 5 years of experience in the finance industry and i am going an EJ route because I didn't think a commission only place would even be feasible. How much product do you need to sell to make 3k/month? - use an average % for commission on different items. Would a place like Waddell & Reed or AXA Equitable who only pay commission and sell mainly insurance even keep a new guy around if they were only pulling in the $ in product that you say?
Thanks.
|
Posted By: Hacksaw
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 8:20pm
I think the real question is what type of advisor do you want to be. If you come from an education career, talk to ice. I would imagine being an ex-educator you could do really well in that niche. I would always start at a place offering a salary. Probably EJ at this point. Reason why is it is always better to have it and not need it, then to need it and not have it. You could put yourself into a bad position financially because this business has the allure of the $1mm+ prospect you have out there that you might close next month.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 8:25pm
Salaries are for bitches.
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 8:40pm
Hacksaw wrote:
I think the real question is what type of advisor do you want to be. If you come from an education career, talk to ice. I would imagine being an ex-educator you could do really well in that niche. I would always start at a place offering a salary. Probably EJ at this point. Reason why is it is always better to have it and not need it, then to need it and not have it. You could put yourself into a bad position financially because this business has the allure of the $1mm+ prospect you have out there that you might close next month. |
This makes me happy to read. Honestly, I make 45K at my desk job now. EJ will give me 30k. One, I'm sure I can make 15k of commission in my first year to "break even", right? That can't be that hard.
I have the day in the life assessment next week, which is the final stage of their hiring process. Does any one have anything to offer up on how to do well at this stage? It sounds like a very exciting exercise. I'm actually really looking forward to it.
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 9:19pm
knockknock wrote:
Iamlegend wrote:
It depends how much you need to make monthly?? If you need 2-4k per month for living expenses you could do that in 6 months. One of the best skills you can have is how to read people and how to build trust. |
Someone with no sales experience, no industry experience can make 3k/month in the FIRST 6 months in a commission only based FA role? Do you really feel this way? I'm not mocking you or anything, I truly want to know what you think. I have 5 years of experience in the finance industry and i am going an EJ route because I didn't think a commission only place would even be feasible. How much product do you need to sell to make 3k/month? - use an average % for commission on different items. Would a place like Waddell & Reed or AXA Equitable who only pay commission and sell mainly insurance even keep a new guy around if they were only pulling in the $ in product that you say?
Thanks. |
I meant after your first 6 months of work in production you should be doing enough to make 2-4k in commissions if you are going to make it. His original ?? was concerning an indy route so if you are indy or RIA and you do 2500-4k in total production in month 7 you would be bringing in that much in income depending on your level of payout. I would personally go somewhere that you get a salary since you can always go out on your own later and I feel having a brand name behind you helps you get clients that you will have a hard time getting otherwise.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/13/2013 at 10:01pm
Moraen wrote:
Salaries are for bitches.
|
Says the guy who started at EDJ...and to my knowledge, is not a bitch.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/14/2013 at 10:35am
Thanks again for your advice. Bit of a mixed message, but in the end sounds like drink the kool aid and cut your teeth gumshoeing neighborhoods, learn the ropes and fail out and hope they don't come after you for their training costs. As to salaries being for bitches, for me it has nothing to do with salary, it only has to do with one thing, getting into the ring and staying on your feet until at least round 3.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/16/2013 at 8:07pm
Hi again. Sorry for so many questions, but I do have a few. I was wondering how, or if, it is possible to get the series 65, set up a RIA, etc. and start from absolutely scratch dialing for dollars from a home office following the 500 day war and build business literally from ground zero? That presumes a good working knowledge of investment products, etc. of course. With no brick and mortar, is it possible to run essentially a concierge practice by meeting with clients in their homes, businesses, etc. or is it mandatory to have an actual store front? Also, since the Judge recommended calling the opposite coast to squeeze a few more hours of activity into a working day, is it feasible to work two cities at the same time and get clients from both. I'm between 2 major metropolitan areas of 4-5 million people each I could reach in 3 hours. I know this probably sounds totally noob, but really, I have no preconceived ideas so I look at all of this from an anything is possible perspective. What is possible/impossible? Thank you very much.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/16/2013 at 8:13pm
|
You don't need a sponsor for the 65 so it is technically possible to start as an RIA from the beginning, if you had the seed money.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/16/2013 at 8:59pm
technically possible is only one factor. could you recommend in your opinion the first 5 or 10 steps to jump into the deep end and start swimming with the other sharks for the chum? you have to get to first base first, then second. everyone has a different philosophy, i.e. start w an insurance company, start w ej, hook up with an indy, etc. technically being able is not at all the same as a step by step path to success. anyway, i'm looking at every single post here in the forum drinking in as much information as possible. thank you for your help. this is a great place with good people.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/16/2013 at 9:28pm
|
1. Set up your RIA with proper filings etc, get your compliance shit in order (speak to a certain member here for guidance. If you publicly state that you desire to speak with that person, no doubt they will PM you. 2. Get a Post Office box/virtual office setup (Regus, etc) you dont need an actual office but if you live on say, elm street, or some other street that is clearly in your area, known as a residential area, my opinion is you need a different mailing address. 3. Get a separate phone number with a virtual PBX service so you have professionally sounding voicemail. 4. Put together some kind of brochure/pitchbook, as a leave behind when you meet with people. 5. Start networking, join your local chamber, get active in it, call CPAs and Estate Planning Attorneys, and ask them for a meeting, tell your story to as many people as possible. 6. Fill in down time by cold calling.
This all of course, assumes that you have some knowledge of financial planning, investing, and generally what you do for people and how you intend to do it, AND that you can verbalize it to people you meet in the form of a value statement.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/16/2013 at 9:51pm
Thank you so very much SF Bob. What, no 7-10? Just 6 steps? So easy a Boglehead could do it. Unless there are more than 6...
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 3:55pm
Hi SFBob, Can I ask how did you get your start? You said you started at 48-49 and I've read everything I can but getting ideas from those who have walked the road seems best. Also, do you or anyone here on the boards do tele-mentoring, as in be willing to give someone a half hour of focused advice on getting their start in this business (not in their city of course). Everything I have read have all said the same thing: Sales sales sales. 3-5 years. 1500 calls a day. 125% effort. 90-95% failure rate. Do the 500 day war. But that's where the advice really fragments. Go EJ, go WFA, go boutique, start here, start there. Get the 7. Get the 66. Don't get the 7. Don't get the 66. Get the CFP. Don't get the CFP. But, where is the best place to cut your teeth and get on the path? Thanks for your help.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 5:40pm
Ok, so here's my story. I started in the industry 18 years ago (at 28) and FAILED miserably. The owner of the RIA actually said that he heard "she's what? 30? She'll never make it". I went to work as a Registered Sales Assistant, then settled bond trades, then went into supervision. Then... Got "eliminated" in 2009 as my firm was preparing itself to be purchased. The writing was on the wall for a while. I talked to a senior advisor and we agreed to let me come on as a Jr. Advisor if I would take some of the CFP courses. The Director, however, didn't think I could do it.
My husband told me it's what I should have been doing all along. I signed on at W&R, hit every first year advisor award level, brought in $3MM in my first year (currently I'm at around $12MM AUM), and am having the time of my life.
Was it youth? Maybe. Was it INEXPERIENCE? Absolutely. Failing out = not being able to pay your rent (at the time it was rent) and needing my mother to send me money so I could move back home...
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 7:25pm
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 7:29pm
trueindigo wrote:
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again. |
Really? Why do you think you don't have enough experience to start at WR? Hell, I recruit for them... If you have the drive and the passion, we'll get you started. And, give you support and training.
Do you mean you don't have enough industry experience to qualify for their transition dollars?
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 7:55pm
Well...actually I guess that was a response based solely upon reading forums, etc, not actual experience. BTW 30 year Alaskan resident , teacher, ran a 501(c)(3) as Ex.Dir. of the Alaska Natural Energy Institute dealing with USDOE, Alaska Science and Technology Foundation, UAF, etc.; flight instructor, law enforcement, etc . Took time off to write 3 books, (published 2) now I'm ready to do something just for me, and FA is fascinating. Motivated? Oh my yes. Persistent, dedicated, 2 degrees (UAF). Cum laude. I'm used to 70 hour weeks. I just have no clear idea where to begin and to whom to speak to get started. Any suggestions would be on bended knee. Thank you.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Hacksaw
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 7:58pm
NewMgr wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again. |
Really? Why do you think you don't have enough experience to start at WR? Hell, I recruit for them... If you have a pulse and can fog a mirror, we'll get you started. And, give you support and training.
Do you mean you don't have enough industry experience to qualify for their transition dollars? | Fixed it for you
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:03pm
NewMgr wrote:
Ok, so here's my story. I started in the industry 18 years ago (at 28) and FAILED miserably. The owner of the RIA actually said that he heard "she's what? 30? She'll never make it". I went to work as a Registered Sales Assistant, then settled bond trades, then went into supervision. Then... Got "eliminated" in 2009 as my firm was preparing itself to be purchased. The writing was on the wall for a while. I talked to a senior advisor and we agreed to let me come on as a Jr. Advisor if I would take some of the CFP courses. The Director, however, didn't think I could do it.
My husband told me it's what I should have been doing all along. I signed on at W&R, hit every first year advisor award level, brought in $3MM in my first year (currently I'm at around $12MM AUM), and am having the time of my life.
Was it youth? Maybe. Was it INEXPERIENCE? Absolutely. Failing out = not being able to pay your rent (at the time it was rent) and needing my mother to send me money so I could move back home... |
You started at an RIA at age 28. If you were 28 again starting at Edward Jones this time around, how do you think you would do?
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:03pm
Hacksaw wrote:
NewMgr wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again. |
Really? Why do you think you don't have enough experience to start at WR? Hell, I recruit for them... If you have a pulse and can fog a mirror, we'll get you started. And, give you support and training.
Do you mean you don't have enough industry experience to qualify for their transition dollars? | Fixed it for you |
HS, I won't start them under those circumstances. But, I'm sure there are some who would.
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:06pm
trueindigo wrote:
Well...actually I guess that was a response based solely upon reading forums, etc, not actual experience. BTW 30 year Alaskan resident , teacher, ran a 501(c)(3) as Ex.Dir. of the Alaska Natural Energy Institute dealing with USDOE, Alaska Science and Technology Foundation, UAF, etc.; flight instructor, law enforcement, etc . Took time off to write 3 books, (published 2) now I'm ready to do something just for me, and FA is fascinating. Motivated? Oh my yes. Persistent, dedicated, 2 degrees (UAF). Cum laude. I'm used to 70 hour weeks. I just have no clear idea where to begin and to whom to speak to get started. Any suggestions would be on bended knee. Thank you. |
Sounds like you have the stamina. Talk face to face with others in the industry. We're a bunch of cynical shits...
|
Posted By: Hacksaw
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:06pm
trueindigo wrote:
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again. | If you can honestly do the 500 day war and continue to proactively get in front of people, where you start will not matter. I do believe it is harder today to make it cold. But then again it was never easy. Every place has their plus and minuses. Every place has the odds stacked against you. You just should talk with all of them and see where you think there will be a fit. After you get a feel for some of the places pick your top two or three, and come back here and ask specific questions. People give eachother crap on here, but it is a fountain of knowledge and an incredible resource.
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:07pm
knockknock wrote:
NewMgr wrote:
Ok, so here's my story. I started in the industry 18 years ago (at 28) and FAILED miserably. The owner of the RIA actually said that he heard "she's what? 30? She'll never make it". I went to work as a Registered Sales Assistant, then settled bond trades, then went into supervision. Then... Got "eliminated" in 2009 as my firm was preparing itself to be purchased. The writing was on the wall for a while. I talked to a senior advisor and we agreed to let me come on as a Jr. Advisor if I would take some of the CFP courses. The Director, however, didn't think I could do it.
My husband told me it's what I should have been doing all along. I signed on at W&R, hit every first year advisor award level, brought in $3MM in my first year (currently I'm at around $12MM AUM), and am having the time of my life.
Was it youth? Maybe. Was it INEXPERIENCE? Absolutely. Failing out = not being able to pay your rent (at the time it was rent) and needing my mother to send me money so I could move back home... |
You started at an RIA at age 28. If you were 28 again starting at Edward Jones this time around, how do you think you would do?
|
Well, I was a lot cuter then...
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:09pm
Hacksaw wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Thanks for your .02. My main focus is where to start. Not enough experience to begin at WR, too old to be cannon fodder for EJ. I think. Making hurdles isn't my objection, being a tool where the odds are stacked purposely is. Where to start? Thanks again. | If you can honestly do the 500 day war and continue to proactively get in front of people, where you start will not matter. I do believe it is harder today to make it cold. But then again it was never easy. Every place has their plus and minuses. Every place has the odds stacked against you. You just should talk with all of them and see where you think there will be a fit. After you get a feel for some of the places pick your top two or three, and come back here and ask specific questions. People give eachother crap on here, but it is a fountain of knowledge and an incredible resource. |
And, we're a cynical bunch of shits! Hahahah! For sure, though. Talk to a few face to face and come back and ask questions. HS is right.
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:11pm
NewMgr wrote:
knockknock wrote:
NewMgr wrote:
Ok, so here's my story. I started in the industry 18 years ago (at 28) and FAILED miserably. The owner of the RIA actually said that he heard "she's what? 30? She'll never make it". I went to work as a Registered Sales Assistant, then settled bond trades, then went into supervision. Then... Got "eliminated" in 2009 as my firm was preparing itself to be purchased. The writing was on the wall for a while. I talked to a senior advisor and we agreed to let me come on as a Jr. Advisor if I would take some of the CFP courses. The Director, however, didn't think I could do it.
My husband told me it's what I should have been doing all along. I signed on at W&R, hit every first year advisor award level, brought in $3MM in my first year (currently I'm at around $12MM AUM), and am having the time of my life.
Was it youth? Maybe. Was it INEXPERIENCE? Absolutely. Failing out = not being able to pay your rent (at the time it was rent) and needing my mother to send me money so I could move back home... |
You started at an RIA at age 28. If you were 28 again starting at Edward Jones this time around, how do you think you would do?
|
Well, I was a lot cuter then...  |
I'm very close to making the jump on to EJ, and I'm turning 30 in 2 months, so you could see my fear about this statement you made. lol. so, seriously...am I putting my family at jeopardy even if I work my ass off?
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:13pm
others in the industry? what's wrong with talking to you?
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:13pm
|
Indigo, i got my start at a wirehouse. Its different today than 13 years ago. I got into the training program, they paid me a salary plus commission and bonuses for 2 years, then salary went away. Structured training program, in the branch, and at a training center in another city. The wirehouses (Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo Advisors, Bank of America / Merrill Lynch) are always looking to hire mature business people with business and life experience, and especially with a network of contacts. Today, you need to go online, look for their ads on careerbuilder, Monster.com, etc, and apply online. But if i were you, i would contact every branch you can find in your area. Ask to speak with the Branch Manager. If you can't get to him, get the name of the Assistant Branch Manager, and ask for some time. Send your resume, then follow with a phone call. If that doesn't work, go there. They will like your persistence. The wirehouse training program has very difficult hurdles, and you have a very high possibility of failing out, which at the wirehouses means getting fired for not hitting your hurdles. But you will get licensed, get good training and experience at most branches, and be ready to find a firm that will take you in without much of a book and let you build it your way.
A word of advice - dont do what i did. Dont spend 5 years looking for answers on the internet and overthinking this thing to death (which with all due respect you seem to be doing). If you think you want to explore this, then just do it. Make the calls, get the interviews and get a job. Ask a lot of questions, find a branch manager who will be proactive in helping/ coaching you (they are few and far between), and latch onto that guy. Think about getting on a team. But for Gods sake, just do it
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:16pm
knockknock wrote:
NewMgr wrote:
knockknock wrote:
NewMgr wrote:
Ok, so here's my story. I started in the industry 18 years ago (at 28) and FAILED miserably. The owner of the RIA actually said that he heard "she's what? 30? She'll never make it". I went to work as a Registered Sales Assistant, then settled bond trades, then went into supervision. Then... Got "eliminated" in 2009 as my firm was preparing itself to be purchased. The writing was on the wall for a while. I talked to a senior advisor and we agreed to let me come on as a Jr. Advisor if I would take some of the CFP courses. The Director, however, didn't think I could do it.
My husband told me it's what I should have been doing all along. I signed on at W&R, hit every first year advisor award level, brought in $3MM in my first year (currently I'm at around $12MM AUM), and am having the time of my life.
Was it youth? Maybe. Was it INEXPERIENCE? Absolutely. Failing out = not being able to pay your rent (at the time it was rent) and needing my mother to send me money so I could move back home... |
You started at an RIA at age 28. If you were 28 again starting at Edward Jones this time around, how do you think you would do?
|
Well, I was a lot cuter then...  |
I'm very close to making the jump on to EJ, and I'm turning 30 in 2 months, so you could see my fear about this statement you made. lol. so, seriously...am I putting my family at jeopardy even if I work my ass off? |
Well your screen name is appropriate then! If you work your ass off there is no better career in the world. If you're putting your family in jeopardy... that only you can answer.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:34pm
|
Knockknock. Yes you are putting your family in jeopardy. It is a big risk.
|
Posted By: MainStreet
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 8:57pm
Moraen wrote:
Knockknock. Yes you are putting your family in jeopardy. It is a big risk. |
^This.
And you probably don't realize the amount of strain it puts on a family. You are, one way or the other, making your wife an unwitting partner in this effort ... and when the crap hits the fan, you might be forced to make some unwelcome decisions.
------------- Trouble is, you think you have time ~ Buddha
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 9:09pm
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 9:23pm
|
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals. Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 9:38pm
Thank you very much. I can do that.
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Hacksaw
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 10:50pm
trueindigo wrote:
others in the industry? what's wrong with talking to you? | Not sure if this was directed at me or not. You need more than annonymus Internet posters. We cannot tell you where is the right place for you, no matter how much information you give us, or experience we've had. Only you know will know that. But they will all tell you what you want to hear because they get compensated for bringing in trainees. My point was that no one here will give you the bs they will. We will give you honest feelings and opinions, but none of that matters if the feeling is not there (of you fitting).
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/18/2013 at 11:01pm
|
To add to what Hacksaw said, we don't know you. What is a good fit for one personality, might not be the best fit for another. You need to decide 1. if you are willing to take the risk, which is clearly high (with potential high reward) 2. assuming you are willing, whats the best fit for you personally. For now, we can only help you in terms of what to look for Once you start, we can help with ideas. But we don't know you, you know yourself.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 12:52am
trueindigo wrote:
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck. |
This is what I would probably do if i were you...
Step 1: Try my best to get hired at UBS if they have a training class this year. If not, I'd go to ML or MS. I'd take my salary, get licensed, and get trained. Once in production, I would ONLY do annuitized business, and I would ONLY take households over $250K. I would assume I'm going to be fired for missing a hurdle. Once fired, I would go to step 2...
Step 2: I would go to WFA. In my opinion, the best wirehouse, and the only one (maybe UBS too) worth staying at long term. I would go to another wire, because they would probably give you a salary as a trainee again, and you could bring your small number of households with you from your first employer. You will probably make it WFA at this piont, as their hurdles are more reasonable, plus you get paid on everything. Continue building your annuitized book.
Step 3 if you succeed at WFA: Make a career at the wirehouse side if you like it, or wait 5 years and go indy via their FINET channel with absolutely no pressure.
Step 3 if you fail at WFA or just plain hate them for some reason: Try to find an open office at EDJ where you can bring your small book, and/or inherit some assets, or go to a bank. Knowing that if you failed twice on your own, inheriting assets or getting warm leads at a bank is really your only chance of success.
Step 4: If you want someday, whether you stay at a wire, EDJ, or a bank, go indy.
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 7:38am
Iamlegend wrote:
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals.Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself. |
How close together would you rank these 3 places? Relatively close together or way far away from eachother?
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 5:05pm
trueindigo wrote:
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck. |
Indigio - I hope you cheese it down a little on the phones and in your emails...as i love your enthusiasm, some of your posts are kinda over the top...just being honest. it's good to get feedback in a non pressure 'forum' if you will
Guys - my wife is on board. she thinks i can do it no problem and i've told her time and time again what a huge risk it is. she still is almost pushing me. i like it. i've always wanted to do this and i just feel that the time is right. my market area is good. REAL good. i think if i get offered the job i'm going to take it. i'm pretty pumped about it no matter how many times i ask on here to how many different people and they say, don't do it, i'm still looking forward to it. weird.
i've also come to thinking that some people on here are recruiters and if they aren't going to have you, then why not talk them out of the industry to cut down on competition any way possible. makes sense to me. i would do it. i recently had a face to face interview with a guy at W&R, he was telling me i can go take my series 7 without being sponsored. just using that as an example to display his intelligence. he was about 80 years old and basically talked me out of the industry. it was a really weird feeling. so, i'm thinking some people on here do it to.
|
Posted By: trueindigo
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 5:17pm
knockknock whoever you are I have never once made a phone call to anyone here. this is a thread I started and people have been incredibly helpful here. really just wonderful. you might consider starting your own thread and get advice specifically for your own needs and cheese it down or up however you like. k?
------------- True Indigo
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 5:30pm
|
Knock , knock. The only person who is very active on here who currently doesn some recruiting that I know of is NewMgr. She posted that she is a mgr with W&R and recruits in that capacity as well as running her book. I used to be in mgt with WFA so I used to recruit.
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 5:37pm
KK, I do recruit, but not on this forum. I don't know who you guys are or where you're coming from, so frankly no thanks.
I suggested Indigo have a CONVERSATION with his local WR manager for intel purposes only...
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 5:44pm
knockknock wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck. |
Indigio - I hope you cheese it down a little on the phones and in your emails...as i love your enthusiasm, some of your posts are kinda over the top...just being honest. it's good to get feedback in a non pressure 'forum' if you will
Guys - my wife is on board. she thinks i can do it no problem and i've told her time and time again what a huge risk it is. she still is almost pushing me. i like it. i've always wanted to do this and i just feel that the time is right. my market area is good. REAL good. i think if i get offered the job i'm going to take it. i'm pretty pumped about it no matter how many times i ask on here to how many different people and they say, don't do it, i'm still looking forward to it. weird.
i've also come to thinking that some people on here are recruiters and if they aren't going to have you, then why not talk them out of the industry to cut down on competition any way possible. makes sense to me. i would do it. i recently had a face to face interview with a guy at W&R, he was telling me i can go take my series 7 without being sponsored. just using that as an example to display his intelligence. he was about 80 years old and basically talked me out of the industry. it was a really weird feeling. so, i'm thinking some people on here do it to. |
KK, you HAVE to have the support of your family. It took my spouse taking me by the shoulders, looking me in the eye and telling me this is what I should have been doing all along to get me to make the jump to production. If your wife is behind you on this one, you should do it. (Oh, wait, since I'm not going to have you shouldn't I be talking you out of the industry???)
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 6:21pm
NewMgr wrote:
knockknock wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck. |
Indigio - I hope you cheese it down a little on the phones and in your emails...as i love your enthusiasm, some of your posts are kinda over the top...just being honest. it's good to get feedback in a non pressure 'forum' if you will
Guys - my wife is on board. she thinks i can do it no problem and i've told her time and time again what a huge risk it is. she still is almost pushing me. i like it. i've always wanted to do this and i just feel that the time is right. my market area is good. REAL good. i think if i get offered the job i'm going to take it. i'm pretty pumped about it no matter how many times i ask on here to how many different people and they say, don't do it, i'm still looking forward to it. weird.
i've also come to thinking that some people on here are recruiters and if they aren't going to have you, then why not talk them out of the industry to cut down on competition any way possible. makes sense to me. i would do it. i recently had a face to face interview with a guy at W&R, he was telling me i can go take my series 7 without being sponsored. just using that as an example to display his intelligence. he was about 80 years old and basically talked me out of the industry. it was a really weird feeling. so, i'm thinking some people on here do it to. |
KK, you HAVE to have the support of your family. It took my spouse taking me by the shoulders, looking me in the eye and telling me this is what I should have been doing all along to get me to make the jump to production. If your wife is behind you on this one, you should do it. (Oh, wait, since I'm not going to have you shouldn't I be talking you out of the industry???) |
I like this forum! You guys(and gals) have been great. informative. entertaining. thought provoking.
Thank you all very much. I'm going to stop hijacking this guys thread..he seems upset about it.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 6:34pm
knockknock wrote:
trueindigo wrote:
Actually SF this is exactly the kind of direction I've been looking for. I'm really not one to spend tons of time trolling and chewing my nails. I would far rather be doing exactly what you've written, just been looking for that one mssg w clear concise advice. I have zero fear of being fired for non-performance, none at all. Tomorrow I'm starting exactly w what you advised. I'll be bahck. |
Indigio - I hope you cheese it down a little on the phones and in your emails...as i love your enthusiasm, some of your posts are kinda over the top...just being honest. it's good to get feedback in a non pressure 'forum' if you will
Guys - my wife is on board. she thinks i can do it no problem and i've told her time and time again what a huge risk it is. she still is almost pushing me. i like it. i've always wanted to do this and i just feel that the time is right. my market area is good. REAL good. i think if i get offered the job i'm going to take it. i'm pretty pumped about it no matter how many times i ask on here to how many different people and they say, don't do it, i'm still looking forward to it. weird.
i've also come to thinking that some people on here are recruiters and if they aren't going to have you, then why not talk them out of the industry to cut down on competition any way possible. makes sense to me. i would do it. i recently had a face to face interview with a guy at W&R, he was telling me i can go take my series 7 without being sponsored. just using that as an example to display his intelligence. he was about 80 years old and basically talked me out of the industry. it was a really weird feeling. so, i'm thinking some people on here do it to. |
Just so we're clear, we don't have any active recruiters on this board right now, and haven't for many, many months. We have had a handful of independent recruiters (aguilartx was the last one, and he's been MIA for months and months), and we have a handful of guys/gals in management roles that recruiting is a portion of their job.
That being said, to my knowledge, there has NEVER been a non-licensed person recruiter to a firm from Advisorheads. Plenty of people seeking intel, but the advice you get on this board is pretty honest with no selfish motives at play. Some members have an axe to grind with their old firm, and some members really drink the kool aid at their current firm, but commentary is never/rarely motivated by self interest for recruiting purposes.
Not sure where you got that idea (not mad about the allegation either, just wanted to set the record straight). We do welcome recruiters by the way, but their recruiting activites must be kept strictly to the Vendor section.
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Feb/19/2013 at 9:24pm
What Ice said. This place is extremely unique, and i don't think anyone is here to recruit, let alone to cut down the body pool.
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: JYD
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 2:24pm
knockknock wrote:
Iamlegend wrote:
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals.Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself. |
How close together would you rank these 3 places? Relatively close together or way far away from eachother? |
I know this was for someone else, but I would rank wfa and rj pretty close to one another from a capabilities standpoint. WFA will have more national reach and wells has better brand recognition than RJ, but RJ is smaller and likely a smaller burocracy to go along with that. Each would have its strong points. Both also embrace open architecture on the investment front. I believe this would allow you to build a more sophisticated practice, if that is what you are looking for, especially from an investment perspective.
Edward Jones is a completely different animal, and there is a lot of detail about that on this board. Very marketing focused, lots of relationships, limited product. Advisory is 20 years behind the rest of the industry at Ed Jones. Then again, who is to say advisory is the only way to do it. If you are looking to market to mass affluent (100 k to 1 million) this could be the best fit. In general, if you are looking to eventually be a million dollar plus guy, it can be done at ej, but it is a lot harder as a result of the number of relationships you will be encouraged to bring in.
Depends on the pool you swim in
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 6:30pm
JYD wrote:
knockknock wrote:
Iamlegend wrote:
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals.Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself. |
How close together would you rank these 3 places? Relatively close together or way far away from eachother? |
I know this was for someone else, but I would rank wfa and rj pretty close to one another from a capabilities standpoint. WFA will have more national reach and wells has better brand recognition than RJ, but RJ is smaller and likely a smaller burocracy to go along with that. Each would have its strong points. Both also embrace open architecture on the investment front. I believe this would allow you to build a more sophisticated practice, if that is what you are looking for, especially from an investment perspective.
Edward Jones is a completely different animal, and there is a lot of detail about that on this board. Very marketing focused, lots of relationships, limited product. Advisory is 20 years behind the rest of the industry at Ed Jones. Then again, who is to say advisory is the only way to do it. If you are looking to market to mass affluent (100 k to 1 million) this could be the best fit. In general, if you are looking to eventually be a million dollar plus guy, it can be done at ej, but it is a lot harder as a result of the number of relationships you will be encouraged to bring in.
Depends on the pool you swim in |
What he said
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 7:03pm
JYD wrote:
knockknock wrote:
Iamlegend wrote:
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals.Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself. |
How close together would you rank these 3 places? Relatively close together or way far away from eachother? |
I know this was for someone else, but I would rank wfa and rj pretty close to one another from a capabilities standpoint. WFA will have more national reach and wells has better brand recognition than RJ, but RJ is smaller and likely a smaller burocracy to go along with that. Each would have its strong points. Both also embrace open architecture on the investment front. I believe this would allow you to build a more sophisticated practice, if that is what you are looking for, especially from an investment perspective.
Edward Jones is a completely different animal, and there is a lot of detail about that on this board. Very marketing focused, lots of relationships, limited product. Advisory is 20 years behind the rest of the industry at Ed Jones. Then again, who is to say advisory is the only way to do it. If you are looking to market to mass affluent (100 k to 1 million) this could be the best fit. In general, if you are looking to eventually be a million dollar plus guy, it can be done at ej, but it is a lot harder as a result of the number of relationships you will be encouraged to bring in.
Depends on the pool you swim in | nicely written. I agree
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 8:43pm
JYD wrote:
knockknock wrote:
Iamlegend wrote:
Of the big firms WFA should be your first choice. Better training than the other wires and more realistic goals.Next is Raymond James & Associates then EJ. Apply and get an interview and sell yourself. |
How close together would you rank these 3 places? Relatively close together or way far away from eachother? |
I know this was for someone else, but I would rank wfa and rj pretty close to one another from a capabilities standpoint. WFA will have more national reach and wells has better brand recognition than RJ, but RJ is smaller and likely a smaller burocracy to go along with that. Each would have its strong points. Both also embrace open architecture on the investment front. I believe this would allow you to build a more sophisticated practice, if that is what you are looking for, especially from an investment perspective.
Edward Jones is a completely different animal, and there is a lot of detail about that on this board. Very marketing focused, lots of relationships, limited product. Advisory is 20 years behind the rest of the industry at Ed Jones. Then again, who is to say advisory is the only way to do it. If you are looking to market to mass affluent (100 k to 1 million) this could be the best fit. In general, if you are looking to eventually be a million dollar plus guy, it can be done at ej, but it is a lot harder as a result of the number of relationships you will be encouraged to bring in.
Depends on the pool you swim in |
Thanks for the input. I live in a very wealthy county, surrounded by other, even more wealthy counties here on the east coast. i live in a small town and am surrounded by small towns full of wealthy people. Is this what you mean by if marketing to mass affluent? because i think i would be doing precisely that. i know that has it's hurdles too, like they already have advisors...well, people are retiring these days so they will have to let some clients go, right? I personally know a good amount of millionaires and some famous people. I'm trying to paint a picture of where I live without telling you. Is this what you mean by depends on what pool i swim in? If i was in the middle of a city trying to do this, I would NEVER want to work for EJ, it sounds dangerous and awful to go knocking on row homes. yuck...at least i'll be knocking on nice sized homes - mini mansions. and the towns that i live near are flooded with small businesses.
could you explain a little more what you mean by it will be harder to be a million dollar guy due to the amount of relationships required, please? i think you mean that since i have to make all these quality contacts per day i have to take everything coming my way instead of focusing just on high net worth people? and how does that make it harder to be a million dollar guy? and what exactly do you mean by a 1 million dollar guy? I make 1 million per year or have 1 million in AUM? Honestly, I would be happy if i took home 80k/year in my 2nd year or even 3rd year. by year 4 or 5 i would hope to be in the 6 figs tho...but i def. don't need 500k/year or 300k/year...i'm cool with 150 or 100...
man, two glasses of wine and i'm on here ramblingb 
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 11:27pm
|
Answers & commentary:
#1: I don't think EDJ is 20 years behind in Advisory. 10 years, perhaps. 20 years, definitely not. Everything else he said about EDJ is true.
#2: At EDJ, you don't HAVE to doorknock. You can build your business however you want for the most part, but like mentioned before, you'll have some limitations on investments that could handicap you in dealing with HNW clients at times. Doesn't sound like you're in a market where EDJ would thrive though to be honest.
#3: The common wisdom is that you need to have a small number of households with a lot of money to grow to a big producer. Meaning, you'd be better off working with one hundred $1 million clients, rather than one thousand $100K clients. Both are at $100 million AUM, but the guy with 1,000 clients doesn't have good relationships (how could you), and is running ragged trying to service them. I don't necessarily agree with this, but that's what they are referencing. I know lots of $750K+ producers that have hundreds of households. It's all about how scalable you make your practice (get a good assistant to handle all service and train clients to talk to him/her for service, and you only for investment advice, put everyone in model driven investmentsso you have 400 clients in one model, 200 in another, etc.). Up to you how you want to do it.
#4: "A million dollar guy" means a million dollar PRODUCER. You'll usually keep about 50 - 70% of what you PRODUCE, depending on what firm you're with and what type of practice you run. So a "$1 million guy" probably makes about $500 - $700K. You can usually ballpark your PRODUCTION by taking .70 - 1.00% of your assets under management. So a good idea would be at $100 million in ASSETS, you would PRODUCE about $700K - $1MM, of which you would keep 50 - 70% of (before taxes).
Hope that helps.
|
Posted By: JYD
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 11:36pm
Regarding the pool you swim in comment, it really has a lot more to do with who you are and who your existing contacts are than it has to do with where you are in the country. If you have a natural market and lots of significantly influential contacts, you could build a practice that is more focused on higher net worth clients. This would mean fewer clients, very high touch and a need for more sophisticated investment product. A wirehouse would be a good fit for this. You wou ld be swimming with the sharks in a competitive environment. If successful you would be more likely to achieve revenue levels above a million a year (you'd get about 45% of that) with this set up because you would have a more manageable book from a service perspective (purely on number of clients). This is very very hard to do by the way.
If your contacts are not as deep, and you don't have a ton of investment expertise yet, Ed Jones might be a good fit. You will have a lot more clients because of the way the "make" you market to survive. You will take 5k IRA accounts and average a much smaller household value. As a result it is hard to break above mass production thresholds because you are servicing so many relationships after 10 yrs or so. Oh, this is also very very hard to do.
Depends on what you want, and who you can get to say yes!
|
Posted By: JYD
Date Posted: Feb/20/2013 at 11:39pm
|
Looks like I was posting while icecold was posting, so some redundancy. I stand behind the 20 years comment. I've been around a while. Of course that is an exaggeration!
|
Posted By: Greenman
Date Posted: Feb/26/2013 at 1:56pm
|
True, you have to work smart, hard, and be dedicated. However, you have to be able to sell. I worked with a guy that worked harder, smarter, and had more designations than me, but ccouldn't make it. The sole reason was because he couldn't sell a freaking life jacket to someone on the titanic. Most of the ones that make it are like a perfect storm.
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 8:27pm
Hey guys. I have an offer on the table with EJ and WFA! Super pumped! Morgan Stanley just contacted me(pretty much out of the blue - kinda weird, but nice. they must have heard about the guy that is crushing all the interviews ) and invited me in.
I'm assuming MS is probably the hardest place to "make it" at out of those three in regards to the hurdles they set?
|
Posted By: NewMgr
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 8:38pm
KK you gotta decide what you want your practice to look like. You've got some great opportunities. Do the pros and cons list and make your decision. Let us know how it goes and GOOD LUCK
|
Posted By: squeaky
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 8:51pm
|
Congrats, those are all nice options. If it were me, I'd take icecold's advice...take the WF gig and if you dont make it, EJ will always take you. But not the other way around.
|
Posted By: Sportsfreak
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 9:02pm
I agree wtih squeaky
------------- If you eat an entire cake without cutting it, then technically, you only had one piece
|
Posted By: knockknock
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 9:55pm
Thanks guys. I'll hear MS out first, probably won't like what I hear and then go red...hey mod, i'm gonna have to change my SN
|
Posted By: Iamlegend
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 10:01pm
knockknock wrote:
Hey guys. I have an offer on the table with EJ and WFA! Super pumped! Morgan Stanley just contacted me(pretty much out of the blue - kinda weird, but nice. they must have heard about the guy that is crushing all the interviews ) and invited me in.
I'm assuming MS is probably the hardest place to "make it" at out of those three in regards to the hurdles they set? |
Stay away from Morgan. They are a disaster. Take the offer from WFA IMO as long as you think you can work with the manager there. If not take the EJ offer.
|
Posted By: JYD
Date Posted: Mar/07/2013 at 10:29pm
|
I started at MS a long time ago. Made all my numbers, but they took an institutional relationship away from me because I was retail. Left immediately. So did the client. Bad place. Run by New York lawyers
|
|